Continuing my series of alternative responses to the New York Times column, The Ethicist, without imposing values on others, here is my take on todayâ€™s post, “Should I Have Talked to My Father About His Cross-Dressing?”
My father died seven years ago. He was 93. When I was getting divorced in the late â€™80s and sharing my sexual woes with my mother, she confessed to me that my father dressed up in womenâ€™s clothes, and that she never could deal with it. She wished she had gone to therapy years earlier when she first discovered it. She made me promise never to talk about it. I later found out that both my sisters knew about this as well.
As my father aged, it seemed as if he might not care if the subject was brought up: He left a makeup tray out in his bathroom, as well as nylons hanging to dry. I knew from my mother that he would get dressed up and go to the drive-through at the bank and other places. But I kept my promise. My father was always tight-lipped when it came to emotions and carried around a lot of baggage from his childhood. His mother died shortly after he was born, and his stepÂmothers supposedly were never very nice to him.
Since he died, I regret never having discussed this aspect of his life with him. I wonder what it would be like for him to see specials on Caitlyn Jenner, for example. I donâ€™t really know if my father was queer, just a cross-dresser or what, but being a freewheeling bisexual myself, I hold no judgment, and I feel that if I had brought the subject up with him, our relationship might have been a closer one. Or maybe he would have clammed up more; I will never know.
Was my mother right in asking me not to mention it? My parents had a history of hiding information. For example, if one of them was in the hospital, they would say, Donâ€™t tell anyone else. That request was easy to ignore. But what about this one? Name Withheld
My response: First, I’m sure you didn’t intend the implication, but “being a freewheeling bisexual myself, I hold no judgment” implies a correlation between bisexuality and non-judgment. Why not just say you hold no judgment, unless you believe a non-freewheeling bisexual person would more likely judge?
Next, you say your mother “made” you promise. Many people consider agreements made under duress not valid. Only you know if that applies to you.
Finally, your question: was she right? Unless you know of some book in the sky that defines absolute rightness and wrongness that I don’t, you’re asking an opinion. She thought she was right, at least when she asked. You’re not sure. Many would think she was wrong. What difference does labeling an act with an opinion make?
Since you can’t change the past, I suggest you think about what to do now. The world is different than when your father grew up. Do you want to talk to your mother or sisters about it now? What can you learn from the experience to improve yourself and your relationships today?
The New York Times response:
Thereâ€™s a moral difference between keeping quiet about whether someone is in the hospital, especially when you havenâ€™t promised to do so, and honoring a promise to your mother not to discuss something with your father. Still, if you had wanted to talk to your father about this, you could have asked your mother to release you from the promise. Or you could have told her that even though you had learned about it from her, you now also had evidence of your own (if that was the case; you donâ€™t specify when you learned about the makeup in the bathroom, etc.) and that, with or without her consent, you planned to ask him about it.
But my suspicion â€” speaking not as an ethicist but as an amateur shrink â€” is that talking with your father about his cross-dressing wouldnâ€™t have brought you much closer. The disinhibitions of age aside, your father doesnâ€™t sound like the kind of person who would have wanted to discuss intimate matters with his children. When your mother made the disclosure, there was less understanding of the complexities of gender expression and identity, and so less of a context within which to discuss it. But even today, we rightly think that people should be able to decide what they want others to know about their gender identity.
My response: First, I recommend using paragraphs.
Next, you asked if you should talk to your sister-in-law about your brother’s advice.
I suggest you change your perspective away from asking strangers yes-or-no questions about if you should or shouldn’t do something to asking yourself open-ended questions of what options you have, what resources you have, what your goals are, what results will come, how much you can improve your communication skills and other productive questions. Compassion and empathy will get you farther than judgment.
You know all these people better than anyone. You can figure this challenge out better than anyone. When you do, you’ll have the added benefit of improving your ability to handle similar challenges in the future.
The New York Times response:
Youâ€™ve made it clear that a portfolio of this sort was in no way a prudent investment for someone in your motherâ€™s situation. Worse, if your eldest brother and his company were profiting from these unwise investments, he was abusing a position of trust. You and your youngest brother should let him know that he owes you all an apology.
Given that his actions were professionally and personally irresponsible, heâ€™s not owed much consideration by any of you. Once youâ€™ve told him that you disapprove of what he has done, you should feel free to spread the news widely through the family. You certainly want to protect your sister-in-law and her mother from exposure to the same risks. In talking to your sister-in-law, you wonâ€™t be the one responsible for any breach in the bonds of family: That began with her husbandâ€™s appalling conduct.
Over the weekend, my friends and I were at a party, and one of them (who had been drinking) confided that she periodically makes herself throw up, and that she has been doing this since she was a young teenager. When she told me, I was surprised, and asked if I should be worried. She said no, that all of her friends knew about it, and that it was fine. That said, I am concerned about her physical and mental health.
The next day, I wasnâ€™t sure what to say, so I acted as if nothing had happened. She said she didnâ€™t remember a lot of things from that night; Iâ€™m not sure if she recalls telling me about her situation. Iâ€™ve also noticed that her attitudes about food, dieting and exercise seem misguided and compulsive, and that she needs a lot of validation about her appearance. I didnâ€™t think these things were a big deal, but now Iâ€™m afraid they might be signs of something more serious.
We are very close, and I donâ€™t want to upset her by bringing the situation up. Do I have a moral or ethical obligation to speak with her about this? Name Withheld
My response: While reading most of your letter, I expected to answer by saying there are experts in the field of eating whose advice would help more than people who ask about ethics or me. Then your question didn’t revolve around how to help the woman.
I recommend asking an expert or two how to help the person (or not if an expert suggests otherwise) over abstract philosophical questions about morality and ethics.
The New York Times response:
It sounds as if your friend has not only bulimia but also â€” if the memory blackout she reported is real â€” an alcohol problem. These are serious conditions with serious long-term health consequences, and they should be treated sooner rather than later. Because she is a close friend, you ought to have her interests at heart, and ignoring these problems isnâ€™t in her interest. So encourage her to seek counseling and offer to accompany her if you think that would help. Too often, we avoid raising issues with our friends because the conversation will be difficult. We fear the relationship may be strained by it. But that risk looks a lot better than a very real alternative here: losing your friend to an early death.
Read my weekly newsletter
On initiative, leadership, the environment, and burpees