Before you think I’m going to condemn all three practices in the title, read on. This post is about values and our culture.
As winter approaches in New York, people keep asking me about not using heat.
I point out that people have lived on this island for something like 7,000 years.
They say some nonsense about not wanting to return to the Stone Age, that they were miserable, or that they could use fire and we in the modern city can’t.
Do they think people just sat around a campfire for three or months? Or that they carried a campfire around with them all the time?
The more I learn about how people lived before fossil fuels and uranium, the more I learn ways they thrived that we can’t imagine. I can’t recommend enough the documentary The Great Dance by the team that later won an Oscar for Octopus Teacher and the site Low Tech Magazine, and the publisher’s episode on my podcast.
When I was a kid, when wearing fur in public was condemned but not as taboo as today, I relative had a fox coat. I remember trying it. It was light and incredibly warm, as if resulting from hundreds of millions of years of evolution. I didn’t wear it out in the winter, but I suspect it was warmer and lighter than any coat I wear today. I remember seeing a video comparing traditional clothes to today’s so-called “technical” or “performance” outerwear, finding that fur won. Sorry, I couldn’t find it just now to link to so I can’t cite that source.
I can’t say for sure, but I think many people lived more comfortably then than now, at least regarding cold. They wore fur. Does wearing fur mean that they were cruel? Look at the hunters in The Great Dance. They weren’t cruel. Are coats made out of plastic shipped around the world in a culture degrading earth’s ability to sustain life not cruel?
Factory farming of any animal is cruel, as best I can tell, and I oppose it and spending money on products that come from it. I don’t fault the people in The Great Dance for killing the animals they do and eating them. If they make clothing from those animals’ flesh, I fail to see the problem.
I see great problems with the systems we’ve created that result in cruelty, but the problem is our culture, not inherent in wearing fur, wearing leather, or eating meat. In practice today, there may be for nearly all Americans no way to avoid contributing to the problems of our culture in wearing fur, wearing leather, or eating meat, but the solution is to change culture to restore values of liberty, freedom, equality, democracy, and security, which my next book goes into more depth about. I don’t see people who condemn the practices trying to change culture in that way.
