This week’s selected media, November 15, 2026: Fossil Fuel Abolition, Egalitarian Societies, Egalitarian Behavior and Reverse Dominance Hierarchy, and a few more anthropology articles; Terminator 2

  • Post published:
  • Post category:Tips

This week I finished:

Fossil Fuel Abolition: Legal and Social Issues, by Karl S. Coplan: The writer was a Professor of Law, Pace University School of Law and Co-Director, Pace Environmental Litigation Clinic and the Elisabeth Haub School of Law. I understand this program is one of the highest rated in environmental law, though I don’t know who rates them. The piece is a 90-page article in the Columbia Journal of Environmental Law in 2016.

I was glad to see someone take seriously the idea of zero fossil fuels and devote space to it. He considered the challenges from legal, cultural, and social perspectives: what can be done with statute, treaty, or amendment? What social change would have to happen first? What precedent is there, for example compared to the civil rights movements of the 1960, prohibition, and abolition?

I’m scheduling a conversation with Coplan. I value the scope and depth. I think he missed some points, but maybe I didn’t understand. He talks about living more sustainably as a drop in standard of living, which makes change seem to require coercion. As of the article’s writing, he knew of no one trying to practice living more sustainably, including those promoting it, so no surprise that, with no experience, none of them can imagine the change brings more liberty, freedom, equality, democracy, and security, not less comfort or convenience.

Egalitarian Behavior and Reverse Dominance Hierarchy [and Comments and Reply], by Christopher Boehm: Publised in Current Anthropology, Vol. 34, No. 3 (Jun., 1993). The author is the Director of the Jane Goodall Research Center, Department of Anthropology, University of Southern California. The paper was awarded the Stirling Prize in Psychological Anthropology in December 1992.

I’d been reading about Boehm for years so finally went to the source. This article reported on his survey of many egalitarian societies to check on his unified theory on how they maintain equality: through what he calls reverse dominance hierarchy. He looked at 48 cultures to see if leveling was intentional and if so how. Leveling mechanisms he covers include public opinion, criticism and ridicule, disobedience, extreme sanction, and more.

Egalitarian Societies, by James Woodburn: The article appeared in the journal Man, Sep., 1982, Vol. 17, No. 3 (Sep., 1982), as best I can tell, and published by the Royal Anthropological Institute of Great Britain and Ireland.

Woodburn lived among egalitarian societies and appears to be one of the main scholars of their anthropology. This paper seems one of his main ones. I found it while following up the article above by Christopher Boehm. This piece describes how they live and organize to maintain equality, such as through (quoting his section headers) Mobility and flexibility, Access to means of coercion, Access to food and other resources—i.e. leveling mechanisms.

Societies all over the world with no ways of coordinating ended up with similar practices. Fascinating.

 

Several anthropology articles relevant to the emergence of inequality, class, and other cultural effects:

Class struggles, climate change, and the origins of modern agriculture: This article treated the impact of the Little Ice Age of 1550–1850 on culture around the world. I consider it valuable to consider the impact of climate on culture, though this article only looked at a little piece. It read like the writer wanted to criticize capitalism more than just understand the impact. Still, I considered learning about enclosure and other class struggles interesting.

Podcast guest John Brooke‘s Climate Change and the Course of Global History: A Rough Journey covered this topic excellently, in my opinion, without the agenda I saw in this article.

Climate, class, and the Neolithic revolution: This piece overlapped with a topic I’m researching for my next book:

why did agriculture emerge independently in so many distant centres in a relatively narrow window of time? Anthropologists and archaeologists disagree on the details. There is no disagreement however that climate change played a major role. 12,000 years ago marked the beginning of the Holocene epoch, and the end of the last ice age

Also:

The genus Homo emerged around 5 million years ago, while the species Homo sapiens, our own, the sole extant species of the genus, emerged around 200,000 years ago. Agriculture emerged only around 10,000 years ago. This transition, which took place independently in at least six global centres, is known as the Neolithic revolution. What relevance does ancient history, or strictly speaking, prehistory, have to today? …

there is a common association between the spread of agriculture and the rise of class society. We wish to challenge the ‘common sense’, promoted by popular writers like Jared Diamond, that we can have agriculture or egalitarianism, but not both.

and

it is believed that agriculture would have initially meant longer and harder work than hunter-gathering. For hunter-gatherers, there was no distinction between work and play, and in fecund environments at least, only a few hours hunting or foraging each day was sufficient for a band to reproduce itself. For this reason, hunter-gatherers have been dubbed ‘the original affluent society’, since leisure was abundant and the work-play distinction absent. So why did they take up agriculture?

and

Conclusions

The emergence of agriculture, and civilisation itself, was made possible by climate change at the end of the last ice age. A few degrees of warming dramatically transformed ecosystems. Agriculture emerged in at least six independent centres, and cannot be explained by a linear, stagist account. Societies chose to revolutionise their mode of subsistence, albeit under circumstances not of their choosing.

I put the bold part in bold. It calls attention to a subtle point: they acted with agency but responding to environmental cues. My book explores what happened here more. Stay tuned.

Hunter-gatherers and the mythology of the market – John Gowdy, followed by Gowdy’s appearance on Nate Hagens’s The Great Simplification: This article

Central to this belief system is the notion of “economic man.” This “man” is naturally acquisitive, competitive, rational, calculating, and forever looking for ways to improve his material well-being. Today those of us in the industrial North hardly recognize the idea of economic man as a cultural belief, as opposed to a universal fact, because it accurately describes most of us. We ration our time from an early age to get the training we need to earn an income; we carefully allocate this income among the dizzying array of goods and services available in the marketplace.

Then:

Neoclassical theory sees individuals as isolated producers and isolated consumers of market goods, competing with one another for scarce resources. One’s value as an individual is largely a function of economic success, of accumulating (and consuming) more wealth than does one’s neighbor.

The view of human nature embedded in neoclassical economic theory is an anomaly among human cultures. In fact, the basic organizing principle of our market economy – that humans are driven by greed and the promise that more is always better than less – is only one way of approaching the economic problem of how to make a living. Many cultures have very different ways of organizing production and distribution.

He then attacks what he calls myths of the market, citing other views from egalitarian societies. He concludes:

The hunter-gatherer literature shows that “economic rationality” is peculiar to market capitalism and is an embedded set of cultural beliefs, not an objective universal law of nature. There are many other, equally rational, ways of behaving which do not conform to the laws of market exchange. The myth of economic man explains the organizing principle of contemporary capitalism, nothing more or less (Heilbroner 1993). It is no more rational than the myths which drive Hadza, Aborigine, or !Kung society.

but doesn’t consider what drives the myths of each place. They aren’t mere choices. They result from environmental conditions, coincidentally what the article above alludes to. Neither article treats the effect of necessary resources that can be controlled with no alternative, or less extreme material means of coercion.

‘Wrong About (Almost) Everything’ – a review of ‘The Dawn of Everything’ by David Graeber & David Wengrow: I appreciated the acknowledgement that the book The Dawn of Everything needed criticism and that this article went into some depth. Then it got into the effects of lunar cycles on women and Engels. Normally I prefer to quote things I find valuable but in this case I’ll quote what looks off the rails to me:

We need to get Planet Earth turning once more, not just physically but socially and politically, too. This will not be done by telling people to stop confusing care with dominance and control. It will be done by supporting the school strikes, singing on their picket lines, extending the action to workplaces, dancing in the streets, blocking traffic, bringing capitalism to a complete halt.

But once we’ve taken control, what next? If we stay on strike too long, we’ll soon starve. So, let’s oscillate. Those weekly school strikes, for example, could, perhaps, be lengthened, joined up and staged once a month, spreading across the world until we’ve released all humanity from wage-slavery. Carbon emissions immediately cut by 50 per cent. Then we go back to work, re-organizing it as necessary. We can risk returning to work only once we’re sure it won’t lead back to capitalism. And we can be sure of that only once we’ve all sworn to be back with our children on their picket line next New Moon. We keep doing this, seizing power and surrendering it, until the world is rocking and breathing once more. Reclaim the future. Neither patriarchy nor matriarchy but, something like, rule by the moon.

I’ve been spoiled by the criticism of the book in the What Is Politics? video series by podcast guest Daniel (who goes by one name). I recommend it highly.

Primitive communism and women’s role in its emergence: I started reading this article but ended up skimming it. It seemed a perfect example of academic word spaghetti. I’m open to someone who read it telling me that I missed something making it worth reading it in more depth. In the meantime, I still do try to get a wide variety of views.


 

Terminator 2: Judgment Day, starring Linda Hamilton and Arnold Schwarzenegger, directed by James Cameron: I saw the dvd at the library near the checkout while returning a book and figured I hadn’t seen it in decades so why not borrow it? Also, the first time I wore my auxiliary uniform and saw my reflection, I thought of the T-1000. Seeing him now, I didn’t think the resemblance was so great, which I guess I’m glad for since he was such a bad guy.

The dvd was some “extreme” version so the movie I watched was over two hours long. My memory wasn’t good enough to tell what was new, but I never felt bored.

Still, until I read reviews afterward, I didn’t realize how many critics consider it one of the best action movies. Yes, the action was exciting and fun, and I guess we shouldn’t judge action movies by depth of characters or subtlety or nuance of plot, but I kept getting distracted by the kid, John Connor, being a smart-ass and Linda Hamilton’s acting not measuring up to, say, Maggie Cheung in In the Mood for Love.

I’ve been spoiled.

On the other hand, it was great to see characters so fit.

Leave a Reply